Innovative Research 2020 Expert review comments FORM FOR JOURNAL PAPERS
Dear reviewer:
Please read instructions on the second page carefully .Label this form with your name [Name _COM.DOC] and type the title and author names below BEFORE beginning your review .Replace all ‘X’ place holders with text . For item -highlight the appropriate response and delete the other option .Place important comments at the bottom . CONSULT OUR SAMPLE MAUSCRIPT FOR FORMATTING STYLES AND THE COMPLETE INSTRUCTIONS ON THE NEXT PAGE and Send your completed form with the manuscript as corrected/accepted to editor17@gmail.comTitle of the Paper:
AUTHORS
- Manuscript fonts and text formatting do/do not follow innovative Research styles.
- Title is appropriate as submitted or I suggest an alternative title:x .
INTRODUCTION
- Is informative and satisfactory and need minor changes .
- Need substantial reduction and condemsation of the matter.
- Contain irrelevant and superfluous references.
Materials and Methods
- Are too lengthy and therefore to be reduced OR satisfactory and needs no alternation.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
- Are sufficient and may be published as such.
- are too lengthy and therefore ,to be reduced as mark in the paper.
- Results are not discussed in the light of correct information.
- Contain irrelevant information.
TABLES/FIGURES/PHOTOGRAPHS
- Tables are numbered ,well arranged and sufficient formatted or No table in the paper.
- Unnecessary tables are included in the text .
- Figures are good /bad quality and reproducible or non-reproducible.
- Photographs are neat & clean and required/not required for publications.
- Authors need not/should consult with an English speaking expert before submission.
- Good scientific support is/is not given for new idea .
- All illustrations are /are not attractive and useful or No illustration are presented in the paper.
- I recommened with no/minor/major corrections or reject this paper as currently written for publication in Innovative Research.
Comments(add lines as needed:..........................................................X
Reviewer name&Email address:...........................................................X
Institutional address(date):...........................................................X)
The Editor IN-CHIEF must receive comments forms from reviewers the Editor –in-Chief will thank expert reviewers formally after the review the final submission OR notifications of withdrawal from the authors. 2020 INNOVATIVE RESEARCH EXPERT REVIEWER GUIDE.
Thank you for agreeing to assist the editorial board and authors in preparing their manuscript for INNOVATIVE RESEARCH.We ask you to evaluate the Scientific content Nomenclature and ETHICS and to ensure that the text is written in clear ,grammatical ,correctly spelled English .Please returned detailed review manuscript to innovative research with expert reviewer comments forms.In your final review ,repeat your most important comments at the bottom of the form to complement those included in your manuscript revision, which you should also return to the EDITOR IN CHIEF .Authors are asked to wait until after two different experts have sent their positive review to the EDITOR IN CHIEF .We will formally acknowledge your assistance after we receive the revised final submission.
Important notes:
- The Innovative research Journal publishes only paper devoted to the science ,enginnering and technology .
- Authors are expected to submit concise,well written and well formatted Text ,free of error ,following the criteria set forth in the INNOVATIVE RESEARCH 2020 guide and 2020 sample manuscript.
- Submission that do not meet Innovative Research Scientific criteria will be rejected by the Editors on the first reading poorly forwarded manuscript return immediately for revision.
- After expert review ,authors will submit their revised manuscript to the Innovative Research.
As expert reviewer,it is your duty to determine whether
- The paper is suitable for journal
- The title is both concise and informative ,clearly starting the ,focus of the paper.
- The text concisely presents topics ,methodologies,data and conclusion.
- All illustrations are instructive and legends (captions) unambiguously explain pictured details.
- DOI(Digital Object Identifier) numbers are provided for literature cited entries when available.
- English grammar is clear and proper, and words are spelled correctly.
- The manuscript is formatted in accordance with INNOVATIVE RESEARCH.